Criminal mistake

By: Larry Cohen

Criminal mistake

An ACBL Hall-of-Famer was guilty of letting emotions turn a poor result into a near bottom. This deal is from the 2025 Life Master Pairs Session 3:

In fourth seat, Vulnerable against not, South held: 

spadesAKJ962
heartsJ43
diamondsAQ6
clubs5.

After two passes, RHO opened 1diamonds icon.  This hand could start with a double and then bid spades, but the chosen overcall of 1spades icon is probably mainstream. The opponents are now passing throughout and partner raises to 2spades icon. The high road (quite reasonable) would be 4spades icon, but this player settled for a natural game try of 3diamonds icon, and then honored the partner's lack of interest and passed 3spades icon. A diamond was led:

 

? 843
? K108
? K72
? J1076
 
  
? AKJ962
? J43
? AQ6
? 5
 

Partner doesn't have much, but those two red-suit kings (instead of club cards) are quite useful. Perhaps partner should have made a counter-try of 3hearts icon? Perhaps we should have bid 4spades icon? Still, with 2 likely heart losers and a club, the game needs spades to come in.

Declarer won the diamond lead and banged down the high spades, finding them two-two. Sigh. Next came a lazy heart to the 10 and ace.  What was South's biggest crime? This was the real deal:

Vul:N-S
Dlr: West
? 843
? K108
? K72
? J1076
 
? Q10
? Q92
? 543
? Q9842
 ? 75
? A765
? J1098
? AK3
 ? AKJ962
? J43
? AQ6
? 5
 

Whether or not you agree with the bidding judgment, it was the lazy play of the heart suit that you should label "criminal." Sure, if West has a doubleton or singleton hearts iconQ, low to the ten will work. But that would mean East started with 5 or 6 hearts--the same East who opened 1diamonds icon. The correct play in hearts is to start with the jack. If East has the AQ, nothing matters. But if West has the Q9 (as in the real deal), South loses only one heart trick (if West covers the jack, declarer later finesses against the 9). Making only 170 was roughly a 10% board. Salvaging 200 (for the second overtrick) would have gotten North-South up to almost average on the board. Once you are in your contract, you can't let emotions get the best of you. Taking his eye off the ball cost South nearly 1/2 a board.