Roadmap

Author: Larry Cohen
Date of publish: 11/01/2017
Level: Intermediate

See if you can do better than a 30-time national champion on this deal from the 2017 Vanderbilt teams. At unfavorable vulnerability, South held:

♠ K7  
♥ KQJ984  
♦ 632  
♣ KQ.
 

His partner opened 1♠ and RHO (a known sound player) overcalled 2♠ (Michaels). Maybe a direct 3NT is possible, but South doubled to show penalty interest (but even in your wildest dreams, the opponents won't play in hearts). LHO bids 3♠ and this is passed back to you. You now try 3NT and everyone passes.

Surprisingly, the opening lead is the ♠10 (standard) and you see:

♠ 53
♥ 76
♦ AQJ7
♣ AJ1097
 
♠ K7
♥ KQJ984
♦ 632
♣ KQ

What is going on? Why didn't they lead a spade? How will you play?

With any "normal" spade holding (like Qxxx or Jxxx), West would have led a spade. Likely he has the ♠A and knew from the bidding that you had the ♠K. Had he led a spade, that would have given you 9 top tricks (if the diamond finesse is on). With this clever lead, even if the diamond finesse wins, you have only 8. A 3-3 diamond break would see you to nine, but that's highly unlikely.

Our expert took the diamond finesse at trick one. That was fine--in fact on dummy's ♠J, East follows suit with the ♠4. Next, declarer played a heart from dummy, trying to sneak his ninth trick. RHO was up to the task. He rose with the ♠A and shifted to the ♠Q to set the contract. This was the Real Deal:

Vul:North-South
Dlr: North
♠ 53
♥ 76
♦ AQJ7
♣ AJ1097
 
♠ A1096
♥ --
♦ K10985
♣ 6532
  ♠ QJ842
♥ A10532
♦ 4
♣ 84
  ♠ K7
♥ KQJ984
♦ 632
♣ KQ
 

Granted, East made a good play when he grabbed his ♠A, but declarer shouldn't have allowed him the chance. The bidding and lead gave him a road map to the winning line. Declarer should cross in clubs at trick two and repeat the diamond finesse. Next come all the clubs and the ♠A to leave:

 

 

 

 

 

Vul:North-South
Dlr: North
♠ 53
♥ 76
♦ 7
♣ --
 
♠ A109
♥ --
♦ K9
♣ --
  ♠ QJ84
♥ A
♦
♣
  ♠ K7
♥ KQJ
♦--
♣ --
 

Declarer plays his losing diamond from dummy and West has to lead from his ♠A after all.