Double Error

Author: Larry Cohen
Date of publish: 09/01/2023
Level: Intermediate

For the second month in a row, we visit the 2023 Senior Team Trials. On this deal, I was West and my partner David Berkowitz was East:

Vul:E-W
Dlr: East
♠ J10954
♥ 6
♦ 876
♣ KQ74
 
♠ AQ87
♥ J1072
♦ J92
♣ 109
  ♠ 632
♥ AK98
♦ AK1054
♣ 5
  ♠ K
♥ Q543
♦ Q3
♣ AJ8632
 

East opened 1♠, South overcalled 2♠ and West made a negative double. With the bad trump split and the ♠Q offside (declarer not likely to guess to drop it), 4♠ East-West was probably going down. But at both tables in the match, North-South sacrificed in 5♠ doubled at their favorable vulnerability.

At one table, West led partner's diamonds. East took three high red-suit tricks and the defense should now set it three tricks. East should play a trump and declarer can't manage to ruff all three hearts in dummy (West gets in to lead a second trump). However, East fell from grace and played a spade a trick three; down only 300. 

It was more interesting at my table. I led a trump (double-dummy, not the best lead). Declarer won in dummy and played a spade to the king and my ace. I wanted to play a second trump, but that would be a bad idea. I knew declarer could win in dummy and play a high spade for a loser on loser play; he'd throw a diamond and have a ton of tricks (down only 2). Instead, I switched to diamonds and partner took his ace-king to leave:

 

Vul:E-W
Dlr: East
♠ J1095
♥ 6
♦ 8
♣ K74
 
♠ Q87
♥ J1072
♦ J
♣ 10
  ♠ 63
♥ AK98
♦ 1054
♣ --
  ♠ --
♥ Q543
♦ --
♣ AJ863
 

Now what? Declarer has to lose a heart, but can he trump the other 3 hearts in dummy? Not if we could lead a second trump. Out of trump, David considered underleading in hearts (hoping I had the ♠Q). There was no need for such a risk. He simply played a diamond. Declarer ruffed and had to play hearts from his hand. If I had the ♠Q, I'd get in with it anyway.

Declarer had a beautiful counter to this play. After trumping the diamond, he should exit with the ♠Q! If an opponent has the ♠AK and not the remaining trump (as was the case), he'd get out for down only 2. But, he carelessly played a low heart. I played the 10, of course (after all the good work, I didn't want to play a lazy ♠7 and risk partner having to win the trick) and finally got that second trump on the table. Declarer had to lose a second heart trick for down 500 and 5 IMPs to our team. 

Notice that at each table, a 200-point mistake was made (East's non-club play at trick four at the first table and South's non ♠Q play at our table).