Best Try for a Twelfth

Author: Larry Cohen
Date of publish: 06/01/2019
Level: Intermediate to Advanced

For the 6th month in a row, our Real Deal comes from the 2018 U.S. Team Trials. South, Vulnerable against not, held:

♠ K103  
♥ Q742  
♦ AQ3  
♣ AJ2.
 

RHO dealt and opened 3♠. As they say, "it is dangerous to bid, but it is dangerous to pass."  South overcalled 3NT, raised to 6NT by partner. How should you play after a diamond lead?

♠ A654
♥ A5
♦ K2
♣ KQ975
 
♠ K103
♥ Q742
♦ AQ3
♣ AJ2

In notrump, I recommend counting top tricks. Here, you can count on 11 (clubs are sure to run). How should you try for the 12th?

One declarer won the ♠K and played the ♠5 at trick 2. Do you like that play? The preempter could have the ♠K, but these days, a white on red preempt doesn't really show anything. It must be better to play on spades. Why?

If spades are 3-3 (or ♠QJ doubleton), you have 12 tricks that way. Admittedly, a 3-3 break is less likely than the 50-50 ♠K play. But, even if spades aren't 3-3, there is a great second chance. If the player with long spades has the ♠K, you will fall into your 12th trick.

 

Here is the Real Deal:

Vul:North-South
Dlr: East
♠ A654
♥ A5
♦ K2
♣ KQ975
 
♠ Q872
♥ KJ86
♦ 8
♣ 10864
  ♠ J9
♥ 1093
♦ J1097654
♣ 3
  ♠ K103
♥ Q742
♦ AQ3
♣ AJ2
 

As you can see, the declarer who led a low heart at trick 2, went down. West took the ♠K and there were only 11 tricks. Declarer's team lost 13 IMPs (the other table was in game) instead of winning 13.  In a different match (all matches used the same deals), declarer led a spade to the 10 at trick 2. It lost to the queen, and West returned a spade. Declarer won the ♠K, cashed the clubs and the ♠A and then took his diamonds. This was the remaining position:

 

 

 

 

 

  ♠ A6
♥ 5
♦ --
♣ --
 
♠ 87
♥ K
♦ --
♣ --
  ♠ --
♥ 109
♦ J
♣ --
  ♠ 3
♥ Q
♦ Q
♣ --
 

On the play of the last diamond, West has to abandon one of the majors. As long as spades were 3-3, or the player with the long spades had the ♠K (as here), the contract makes. This is a much better shot than putting all the eggs into the ♠K onside basket.