Larry's Advice

Should I Transfer?

Your partner opens 1NT.  You hold:

s.gif (111 bytes) J7642
h.gif (112 bytes) 102
d.gif (109 bytes) Q32
c.gif (113 bytes) J32

Should you transfer to 2s.gif (111 bytes)? Or should you leave it in 1NT?

What about:

s.gif (111 bytes) 87642
h.gif (112 bytes) 82
d.gif (109 bytes) 832
c.gif (113 bytes) 832 ?

What about all the other lousy hands with a 5-card major?

I used to try to use my judgment. Maybe with the second hand (no outside help), I would have transferred. Perhaps the first hand (with the side queen and jack) was more suitable for notrump, so I would have passed.

Sometimes I guessed right, sometimes not. I'd drive myself crazy.

Now, I have a better solution. I always (as 100%) transfer. Whenever I have a bad hand (no game interest) with a 5-card major, and partner opens 1NT, I transfer to the major. This has been working more than well enough, and I can free my brain to worry about other (more difficult) areas of the game. I no longer have to worry about zigging when I should have zagged.

A few notes:

1) If partner has made a 1NT overcall, that changes things a bit. Now, I don't automatically transfer with all 5-card majors. If I have length in the opponents' suit and/or lots of notrump-looking cards, I might leave it in 1NT. For example, LHO opens 1h.gif (112 bytes) and partner overcalls 1NT, I'd probably pass with :

s.gif (111 bytes) J7642
h.gif (112 bytes) J32
d.gif (109 bytes) J32
c.gif (113 bytes) 32.

With partner likely having heart length (picture h.gif (112 bytes)Q1054), we rate to do poorly in spades. Furthermore, partner's 1NT overcall could sometimes be off shape, and might even include a singleton. He might overcall their 1h.gif (112 bytes) opening with 1NT holding:

s.gif (111 bytes) K
h.gif (112 bytes) Q1054
d.gif (109 bytes) AQ103
c.gif (113 bytes) KQJ3.

Opposite such a hand, it would not be fun to play in 2s.gif (111 bytes).

2) If partner overcalls (typically after an opposing preempt) with a strong and natural 2NT or 3NT, I don't automatically transfer. High-level notrump overcalls, while "natural and balanced," are often off-shape. Especially a 3NT overcall can be based on a running suit. So, when my partner overcalls notrump at a high level, I am not in any rush to transfer to a so-so 5-card major.

 

Those 2 little notes are minor points. Please don't lose my main lesson, which is to try my theory of always transferring to any 5-card major when partner opens 1NT and you have a bad hand.

Return to Larry's website